Home About Practica Musica About Counterpointer About Songworks Exploring Theory
Ordering Installers Web Students Music library Activity Library
Contact / Support Academic Info Ask Theory Questions Latest News Downloads
A slur with a line through it.
Question: 1. In piano music what is a slur with short vertical line at the midway point of the slur marking? How is it played? 2. When a notation or ornament is put in square brackets, does that mean it is optional? D.T.

Answer: Hey, that's two questions. But alright. The first is not standard slur notation, meaning it's not referenced in Gardner Read's Music Notation, the authority on the topic. However, I've seen a vertical slash used to cancel a slur editorially. The slur is there, but the slash suggests to break it. The implication is different, though, from a dotted line slur, which I'd expect to be a more normal editorial suggestion. The dotted line slur means the editor thinks this might be a good place to add a slur, but implication of that vertical line is that the original is slurred yet the editor recommends against it. That I've seen marked by hand in orchestra parts, where the concertmaster is suggesting ignoring a slur found in the original.

If anyone out there has a better idea, let that person come forward.

As for number 2: Brackets in that context would normally mean that the notation or ornament is the editor's suggestion: the editor thinks this could be appropriate though not marked in the original score.

Knowing the identity of the original score would help in answering both questions. Music notation gets progressively more spare in marking as you go back in time. Baroque music was not notated in near the detail of modern music; much was assumed, much left up to the performer. In older music especially one is more likely to see editorial suggestions, or corrections to an earlier editor's editorial suggestions.

Return to Q&A Index

Practica Musica® | Counterpointer™ | Songworks™ |  Free Online Textbook
Ordering | Installers | WebStudents | Conducting Notes | Activity Library | About Us
Contact/Support | Academic Info | Theory Questions | Worksheets | Movies | Site

Ars Nova Software, LLC